What Happened to Reddit
Reddit's Q3 2026 shareholder letter, filed with the SEC on October 29, said search referral traffic "was down meaningfully in Q3, with the decline accelerating later in the quarter", and that in October search traffic had dropped "by more than 1 million referrals on average per week". It warned that daily active uniques could fall by a low double-digit percentage from 130 million. The letter didn't name Google, but on the earnings call CEO Steve Huffman said AI Overviews and AI Mode were the "largest part" of Reddit's working theory, that AI Mode "does not drive traffic", and that "Google is crawling us as hard as ever". The stock fell about 29% on October 30.
Reddit's response is to test a logged-in-only experience in some non-US markets in the fourth quarter. That suits a platform with 130 million daily users. It won't work for most sites. The steps below will.
Step 1: Find Out Whether It's Happening to You
In Search Console, compare clicks and impressions by page for the last 90 days against the same period a year ago. The AI pattern is impressions steady or rising while clicks fall, on informational queries first. If impressions fall too, the cause is more likely a ranking or indexing change. Don't put every drop down to AI.
Step 2: Sort Pages by Exposure
| Page type | Exposure to AI answers |
|---|---|
| Definitions, how-tos, quick facts | High. The answer is enough for most readers |
| Opinions, discussions, reviews | High for Reddit-style content, which AI summarises |
| Product, pricing, tools, calculators | Lower. The reader needs to act on the page |
| Original data and research | Cited often, clicked sometimes |
Step 3: Measure Citations, Not Only Clicks
A page that lost clicks may still be the source behind AI answers. Track whether AI Overviews, AI Mode, ChatGPT and Perplexity cite and name you for your main queries. If you are cited but not named, see fixing ghost citations. Being named in the answer is the part of search value you can still win.
Step 4: Give Readers a Reason to Click
Summaries replace pages that can be summarised. Add what a summary can't: tools, calculators, original data, downloadable templates, current prices and stock, and community. Put that value near the top so the AI snippet points to it.
Step 5: Build Channels Google Doesn't Control
Email lists, accounts, apps and direct traffic don't depend on a results page. Reddit's logged-in test is an extreme version of the same idea. For most brands, the realistic version is a newsletter or a free account offered on the pages that lose the most clicks.
Step 6: Decide Your Crawler Policy on Purpose
Huffman's point, that Google crawls as hard as ever while sending less traffic, is why some publishers now limit AI use of their content. For brand sites that is usually a mistake, because being in the answer matters more than the click. For publishers it is a real choice. See the shared AI training signal and Cloudflare's AI bot controls.